SAAI: Cannabis Bill is ‘contradictory and confusing’
The South African Agricultural Initiative (SAAI) has called for regulated legal trade in cannabis products. It has rejected the Cannabis for Private Purposes Bill in its current form as “contradictory” and “confusing”.
SAAI’s media relations officer Chantel Kelder said on 19 May 2022 that the organization had made a public submission opposing sections of the Bill. Kelder said: “In September 2018 the Constitutional Court made room for Parliament to rectify ‘constitutional defects’ in 24 months, but 44 months later that still has not been done. The Cannabis Bill makes matters even worse by criminalising practically all commercial activities and at the same time ‘authorising’ general “commercial activities” related to cannabis. This contradiction creates confusion that undermines the rule of law.
“While the recreational use, consumption, and cultivation of cannabis by adults in private have been legalised under the right to privacy, practically all private cannabis trade is prohibited by the Cannabis Bill. This is irrational. If the public is allowed to eat pork, the farmer must be allowed to sell bacon”
SAAI is an organisation that protects the rights and interests of family farmers and “promotes a legalised and carefully regulated cannabis industry that boosts economic growth while curbing harm”.
Law is incentivising cannabis abuse rather than permitting simple purchases
Kelder said the Bill would extend the “current regime’s perverse incentives to abuse cannabis regularly in high quantities rather than permitting simple purchases”. She said “the Constitutional Court highlighted medical evidence that shows it is safe for adults to smoke ‘one joint of dagga’ occasionally but dangerous to do so heavily and regularly. Still, the Cannabis Bill practically forces someone who would like to smoke ‘one joint of dagga’ a month to grow an entire plant that could produce 500 ‘joints of dagga’ every harvest. This is as irrational as the law would be to allow alcohol consumption, but only if individuals brew their own ‘mampoer’ in 100-liter barrels.
“The absurd and contradictory regulations must be understood in the context of South Africans’ twin troubles – unemployment and corruption” she said.
“The more contradictory the law, the more discretionary powers are given to officials; the more slow-footed the progression to simple legislation, the more opportunity there is for government employees to extort businesses for licenses and for businesses to circumvent the acquisition of licenses. This is not acceptable.
Ammend the Bill to allow legal cannabis trade without delay
“To avoid this, the Cannabis Bill must be amended to allow legal trade without delay. Officials should be kept at arm’s length, and laboratories should be independently used by growers to test products against toxicity.
“A major benefit of straightforward legislation is that resources currently wasted on policing adults that buy ‘one joint of dagga’ can be diverted to stopping cannabis from getting into the hands of minors and other serious crimes. With over 12 million jobless adults, the South African unemployment line could stretch from Cape Town to Cairo. Unemployment is especially problematic in rural areas. The government’s promise of 130 000 legitimate jobs in the local cannabis industry is probably overestimated.
“Still, if the Cannabis Bill is amended as Saai suggests, tens of thousands of jobs can realistically develop, especially at the family-business level and amongst traditional growers. Job growth must be a priority.
“Cannabis, like tobacco and alcohol, is not for everyone. But once consumption has been decriminalised, the next step has to be making the market work. The law must allow farmers to combine soil, seed, sunshine, and labour into a product that some adults enjoy privately and responsibly.